Ziff Davis Internet
News & Resources for the IT Reseller
NewsReviewsTech AnalysisCommentarySecurityLinux/Unix
My Account |  

John Moore  
Is IT Outsourcing Losing Luster?
By John Moore, Ziff Davis Internet

J. Sainsbury's recent decision to part company with Accenture has inspired mixed interpretations among industry watchers.


The UK food retailer late last month announced plans to take back in-house the IT services it outsourced to Accenture in November 2000.

Under the $3 billion deal, Accenture succeeded in improving Sainsbury's IT capability and "delivered improvements in systems stability and operational cost reductions," according to a joint statement.

But the statement said Sainsbury's IT focus has changed in light of its "Making Sainsbury's Great Again" plan. The program, which aims to boost the company's revenue growth, includes the marketing tag line, "Try Something New Today."

Some industry observers view the split as symptomatic of a broader re-evaluation of older and complex outsourcing projects.

Earlier this year, Sears, Roebuck & Co. terminated a $1 billion-plus outsourcing deal with Computer Sciences Corp. Last year, JP Morgan Chase ended its outsourcing pact with IBM.

"It's a function of where we are at in the market," said Stan Lepeak, managing director of research at EquaTerra Inc., an outsourcing advisory firm.

PointerDisney delegates IT to outsourcers. Click here to read more.

"A number of larger deals are getting older now. We're getting to a point where there is going to be a renegotiation, with user organizations rethinking the original decision."

In April, nearly two thirds of the enterprise respondents to a Deloitte Consulting LLP survey said they have brought some outsourced services back in-house.

Another factor for this: companies that have come to view IT as more strategic want to reassert control. Sainsbury wants to control IT for competitive advantage, said Lepeak, who noted that JP Morgan had a similar motivation for ending the IBM deal.

But Douglas Hayward, an analyst at market researcher Ovum, cautioned against drawing too many conclusions from the Sainsbury split.

In a research brief, he disputed the notion that Sainsbury's action signals a trend toward "insourcing" among large corporations.

"We think that Sainsbury's insourcing comes from particular circumstances, rather than structural factors, but it certainly shows what can go wrong in any outsourcing deal," he wrote.

"We've discussed the Sainsbury case before, but the problems included poor decision-making by Sainsbury executives, weak outsourcing governance, political in-fighting at the retailer and a risky 'big-bang' approach that made too many assumptions and took too many risks."

Channel Insider Special Report: IT Spending in the Channel

At any rate, insourcing—or backsoursing as it has been called—is nothing to pursue lightly. Lepeak described the process of reabsorbing an IT operation as "very painful." Outsourcing buyers may face financial penalties for prematurely ended contracts, he noted.

But the key question is whether an outsourcing customer has the skills on hand to run an IT shop. Lepeak said some customers may inherit some of the contractor's employees.

But that may not be the case when it comes to management-level personnel. "Senior managers are not likely to come back in-house," Lepeak said.

The Sainsbury/Accenture statement said "a number of Accenture employees" will migrate to Sainsbury, but did not provide specifics.

Next Page: BearingPoint and EMC collaborate.

1 | 2 | 3   next >



Help boost your sales with BONUS PACKS.
Let BONUS PACKS help you sell more PCs—with up to $1,200 in valuable products and services. Visit
Buy Local Partner site >>

Join the Microsoft Empower program for ISVs.
A relationship with Microsoft allows you to compete with the big dogs. Learn more about resources, tools and training. Get the documentation >>

Test your licensing I.Q. and get a smart offer.
Take Microsoft's brief Windows® Licensing Pop Quiz and receive a free Windows Licensing Kit - only five questions. Take the quiz now! >>
Free Hands-On Training Lab
Find out how key features of SBS 2003 can help you open up a new line of revenue. Register now >>

SBS 2003 Sales Reference Card
This handy reference card contains features at a glance, sales objection handling, pricing guidelines & more. Get it now >>

Microsoft Empower for ISVs rewards your big idea with big benefits and support.
Access key development tools at a low cost to help you develop that idea into an innovative application. Learn more >>

Changing Business for the Better: A Practical Guide to BPM

This paper provides an overview of the benefits of BPM technologies and identifies the characteristics of BPM solutions that lead to successful BPM process-centric integration projects.

Download this free white paper to learn more!

>> brought to you by IBM

Attention Microsoft Solution Providers!

Want to gain a competitive edge? Try Microsoft Watch – FREE!

Each week you receive:
  • Microsoft News and Insider Information
  • Expert Analysis
  • Code Names of Upcoming MS Products
  • Year-Ahead Calendar, updated monthly

    Click Here to sign up now for your FREE 14 Day Trial to Microsoft Watch.

    White Boxes
    MS vs. IBM
    Linux in the Channel
    Stay in the Zone
    Put The Channel Insider on your desktop.
    Subscribe to The Channel Insider: Channel News, Reviews, Resources and more.

    Make your selections below:

    Contract Watch

    The Channel Insider Update

    Preferred e-mail format:

    Enter your e-mail:

    view all newsletters >>
    Channel Insider Quick Links
    Ziff Davis Footer Logo